What do the next 4000 emoji look like?

jenniferdaniel.substack.com

69 points by lacieargyle 2 days ago


rmah - 12 hours ago

Personally, I think adding emojis to UNICODE was a mistake.

chrismorgan - 14 hours ago

One big problem with this interpretation: expressivity is severely limited with computer text compared with handwriting where you can do what you want, and Unicode is about encoding what already exists, not creating anything new. You could say things like emoji skin tones are an exception to that rule, but modifiers are very limited in Unicode due to how it’s all implemented, and can’t develop in the way described near the end.

monomania - 13 hours ago

If anyone in the unicode consortium is reading this, we really, really need a chainsaw emoji.

gertrunde - 10 hours ago

Perhaps something that illustrates my feelings about emoji... I had to individually select two of the emoji in the article and do a search for them in order to work out what they were... (they turned out to be oyster and fireworks, and seven didn't render at all...

(Anther set of searches tells me that some of the ones that didn't render were 'anatomical heart', tamale, 'heart hands', 'face holding back tears' (another one I would have struggled to divine the meaning of)

groceryheist - 12 hours ago

Clever and fun read. Helps me think of emojis' literary affordances.

Here on a website that deprives us commenters of emoji, I feel expressively constrained.

Or maybe I'm too lazy to remember how to express myself with Japanese emoticons.

Will we get a trainman for the emoji era?

<3

AnonC - 9 hours ago

> Emoji aren’t a language you can speak with your voice, and yet they give us a voice. They are the facial twitches and raised eyebrows that flat text stripped out of speech.

I love, love, love emojis and use them quite often in chats. They add emotion, whimsy, tone, and more. I can’t imagine text chats without emojis. I know that each emoji may mean different things to different people and also different things in different contexts. That makes it more appealing and inclusive (for and of people).

The biggest issues I have with emojis are:

* Too many emojis that I don’t know exist (search isn’t useful when you don’t really know or can express clearly what you’re looking for…Emojipedia helps sometimes).

* Too few emojis or no emojis for what I really want to convey.

* No way to flip any emoji vertically or horizontally or both. C’mon Unicode Consortium, you can do this!

slazaro - 8 hours ago

The only times that I've wanted more emojis is when I'm creating a markdown file that I just want displayed as the rich html version, and I want some icons there, and emoji are the natural way because they're just unicode. Especially if it's a technical document that makes references to a UI, I feel like I want to use emojis as icons like you use FontAwesome, and i can get ~80% there, but I would benefit from more interface icons there. I've never needed extra emojis for texting though.

singularity2001 - 6 hours ago

This motivated https://github.com/pannous/uniscript

Demo: https://pannous.com/uniscript/

negura - 13 hours ago

This analysis and comparison to ancient glyphs completely overlooks how emojis are tied in to technology manufacturers and therefore their profit interests. Emojis have been a major driver of the planned obsolescence business model. iOS (and even Android before version 12) requires a full operating system update if you want to get the newer emojis; eventually, that means having to buy a new Apple device. The constant addition of new emojis (and their essential role in social media) is one of the many pressure points that Apple uses to get their existing users to buy new devices.

netsharc - 4 hours ago

I wonder if 2 (or more) people with no common language ever successfully communicated with each other using emojis...

treyd - 10 hours ago

The footnote is slightly incorrect, the hyphen in emoji is in the wrong place. It's "e" for "picture" and "moji" for "character".

- 2 days ago
[deleted]
urbandw311er - 10 hours ago

> What do the next 4000 emoji look like?

They probably look like this: □ □ □ □ □ □ …

eviks - 10 hours ago

> Fortunately, thousands of years of writing systems walked so emoji could run .

This fortune is imaginary, otherwise you would've skipped "the inventory phase" with emojis because you've supposedly learned to walk thousands of times in those thousans of years

badc0ffee - 9 hours ago

Hopefully more facial expressions and hands, and not more useless fruits/vegetables/foods.

theendisney - 13 hours ago

So many useless symbols but no feed icon.

jimbobimbo - 12 hours ago

Still no diaper emoji. :(

syngrog66 - 7 hours ago

I have precisely 0 use for the emoji which already exist.

bbor - 13 hours ago

Pretty good writeup! Missing some very fun details, though, which is normally fine but... well, the final paragraph is just hard to stomach. If that's not Claude I'll eat my hat.

Regardless, let's discuss the real issue here: Hacker News should support emojis, and it's goddamn ridiculous that it strips them! Like the hatred of markdown, this is a relic from an older tiem kept around for no good reason; either the three (quite well-meaning) mods are in some Eternal-Eternal-September neurosis, or the owner of this public forum is and they don't bother pushing back. Regardless: boo :( / DX<

EDIT: I now realize that this "pretty good writeup" is by one of the people in charge of Emojis, and thus just made some aggressive editorial decisions. Leaving this comment up to remind others to check the Substack's author before commenting!

ryanisnan - 13 hours ago

I mean, why can't you just add another 4000? Search in emoji list works well enough.

kmoser - 13 hours ago

One obvious missing modifier is the ability to animate them. There are a gazillion possibilities here, from the simple (slowly rotating or pulsing) to the complex (morphing one emoji into another). Some apps already do this when showing a reaction emoji for the first time by "popping" them into view, but I predict the next generation will allow the user to apply their own simple animations. The key will be to prevent them from being too annoying, like the dreaded <blink> tag of yore.

assimpleaspossi - 12 hours ago

All emojis are childish nonsense. The article shows what it calls emojis but I would call symbols. I don't care if you think you're having fun. If you use them you are acting like a child.

vlyan - 13 hours ago

[flagged]