Verification Is Not Knowledge: Science needs more than answers

blog.cosmos-institute.org

244 points by ersinesen 3 days ago


throw0101c - 3 days ago

When Kepler published his models:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kepler%27s_laws_of_planetary_m...

People did not understand how or why they worked, but they switched over to them from the Ptolemaic (Tychonic, etc†) system anyway because the math was easier. It was only later (Newton, Einstein) that we understood the "why" and "how".

† https://tofspot.blogspot.com/2013/08/the-great-ptolemaic-sma...

niemandhier - 3 days ago

We all know Terry Tao, do you know Peter Scholz?

Fields medalist and as Tao listed as one of the most important mathematicians of our age.

Scholz is known to find „precisely the correct and cleanest way to incorporate all the previously done work and find an elegant formulation for that — and then, because he found really the correct framework, go way beyond the known results“

In a way that man is the complement of an AI, he generates understanding rather than just proofs.

Maybe he is the right template for the mathematicians of the future.

https://www.quantamagazine.org/peter-scholze-and-the-future-...

wqtz - 3 days ago

Ahhh, epistemology... Does any academic researcher even care about these things anymore?

If you're in academia, you've probably noticed a major shift recently. Research production at an industrial scale through AI.

Grants have "always" been awarded to professors based on quantity multiplied by quality. Now, some professors are churning out 1–3 papers a month with the same group of co-authors. All the grant money goes to them. Grant givers are just only counting the numbers of papers being published.

The Industrial Revolution has hit academia, and some academics are busy arguing for the artisanal value of research while some are creating factories for research.

A_D_E_P_T - 3 days ago

The article's perspective reminds me of math class when I was a kid. The teacher didn't want the right answer alone, she wanted to see how I got there. In an absolute sense, the right answer is the right answer with or without my understanding, but that's not how the class was graded. We're approaching a point where AI is to science as my old calculator is to elementary school math -- it's capable of leapfrogging to answers faster and more accurately than we can.

Thing is, though, verification is knowledge itself. And if we can get to a point where the important questions have answers, we can surely have the verifiers explain those to us in ways we can understand them.