Giant canyon on Mars is still tectonically active
lamont.columbia.edu148 points by gmays 4 days ago
148 points by gmays 4 days ago
The bit of mars that fascinates me is the Hellis Planitia[1] A huge hole roughly opposite the globe from the large volcano complex[2] coincidence.. I think not.
I am vaguely surprised it was not higher rated for a rover mission. 7k meters down should do something interesting to the atmosphere if nothing else.
1. https://trek.nasa.gov/mars/#v=0.1&x=72.07800218650755&y=-42....
2. https://trek.nasa.gov/mars/#v=0.1&x=-116.4913302335018&y=16....
Yeah it's the one place that crosses the triple point of water, not by a huge margin, but likely enough to trigger planetary protection concern.
But there's places like the araneiform terrain where you likely get much higher transient pressures, and maybe they create enough of a greenhouse effect to warm up before they burst through the CO2 ice crust. They'd be a great way for life to spread mechanically using those pressurized bursts.
I wonder how long the conditions would need to persist for anything biological to actually take advantage of them
Similarly, I wonder how long those conditions would need to have ceased to cause harm for those biological anythings
If there is life on Mars, it will be underground.
So if you can get 7km down without digging, that's the first place to look!
I really hope we'll see humans on Mars in my lifetime. For all the amazing success that rovers had, starting with Spirit and Opportunity, and now with Curiosity and Perseverence, having a bloke with a shovel can likely be more productive in a few days than years of missions combined...
The recent findings about the dust being so fine it can penetrate the blood-brain barrier is a real concern though. The more we learn about the planet, the more it sounds pretty unsuitable for habitation.
The cosmic radiation alone poses a major problem, let alone the logistics of supplying water/air/food. I am much more optimistic for a research outpost on Luna.
Though the person you commented on didn't refer to habitation specifically I think, just humans on the surface.
I tend to agree with your thoughts on the moon. Realistically we should be looking at orbital manufacturing and refuelling in our local neighbourhood first and use Luna as a staging area for any deeper missions, of which I feel there's far more interesting features to look at (i.e. Titan, Europa etc)
I don't really think so. To start with there's a lot of really interesting concepts in terms of habitation for Mars. For instance the water/air stuff is oddly enough solved simultaneously, alongside fuel. The Sabatier Reaction [1] and various other characteristics of Mars really make it all feel like a video game where Mars is just clearly level 2. The reaction itself is CO2 + hydrogen = methane + water.
Since Mars atmosphere is 95% CO2 you're pretty much good to go there with a moderate supply of hydrogen. And conveniently enough electrolysis of water yields of course hydrogen and oxygen. And water is shockingly widely available on Mars given the regolith is 2-5% water by volume (giving the unit bastardization of 1 cubic foot of regolith = 1+ liter of water).
Most of the issues people are concerned about like radiation aren't, in reality, that big a deal. I say 'in reality' to mean that the radiation isn't enough to just give you immediate radiation sickness, so the real effect will be a probably reduced life expectancy due to greater rates of cancer. Even that isn't so clear for reason outside the scope of this post, but it's not a show stopper in any case. In general early colonists will have a significantly reduced life expectancy - it's just the nature of colonization, and always has been.
---
Beyond that the Moon is a nightmare. Relatively minimal resources, 2 week long days/nights that vary between way beyond boiling hot and something close to absolute zero. No atmosphere at all so no protection against meteorites, somewhat higher radiation than Mars, and so on. There's also gravity very near zero which can pose some issues with various processes (industrial/etc).
And other destinations like Europa not only have dramatically more difficult 'local settings', but also have significantly greater distances. For instance Europa is about 10x as far as Mars and a somewhat more difficult trajectory to manage. In practice you're probably looking at upwards of 5 years for a one-way trip. We probably need to level up the tech tree a few bumps before realistically looking at things like that and Mars is a good way to do that.
I've got to strongly disagree with Mars being "level 2" anything. Just the 6-9 month trip to Mars would expose humans to a lifetime of radiation; a "standard" mission to Mars -- voyage plus 1.5 years on-planet and back -- would expose astronauts to a total of hundreds of years radiation. When calculating total exposure per astronaut, you'd obviously have to include their (normal) exposure on Earth as well. Not great!
Having said that, there would also be the cumulative effects of low/no gravity on astronauts. Even a year on the ISS has profound negative effects on the human body. And humans have cumulatively spent less than a month total on the moon. We have no idea how astronauts would fare on Mars for 18 months, but it would likely be very bad. And then they'd have to successfully get home.
You also have abundant toxic chemicals in the Mars regolith. Whatever technology we'd use to extract drinking water from it would have to filter out perchlorates, which are extremely toxic to both mammal and plant life. AFAIK we've never done this at all on Mars, and now we're talking about having to do it successfully for 18 months (even with water recycling). Not easy!
To be fair, a lot of proponents of human Mars exploration -- particularly here on HN -- see astronauts as essentially disposable. "Who cares if they risk dying of cancer / poisoning / suicide? It's worth it!" But if you prioritize astronauts surviving both the mission to Mars and the return home there are many, many, many unanswered questions, questions which may indeed have no good answers at all.
Before you accuse me of being a hater: I fully support exploration of Mars, and the rest of the solar system. And the best way to do so, by cost and every other conceivable metric, is with robots. Lets spend way more on space exploration, do it with probes of all varieties, and learn more in our lifetime than in all previous human lifetimes put together!
Your numbers are quite off. The ambient radiation level on Mars is less than what astronauts on the ISS experience. And that's direct exposure. We've had numerous astronauts spend years in space in total. That'd be the equivalent of sunbathing on Mars, which is obviously not exactly the plan there. And so far whatever effect the increased radiation has had is small enough that it's not statistically detectable.
Some misleading articles (or one heinous book) try to count in-transit space weather events as part of the average to bring the numbers to the point of absurdity, but that's plainly lying. Space weather events (like solar flares) are immediately lethal if not shielded against. Fortunately they're easy to shield against since they're predictable and all settlement ships will happen to have one of the best possible radiation shields in large quantities on board - water. Similarly for perchlorates. These can be filtered out with basic water purification tech and trace amounts are even present in much of what we consume on Earth, especially in certain areas.
I'm not accusing you of being a hater, which is quite pointless. But I would say you've probably been misinformed. And I suspect precisely by one book written by a comic book artist. Somebody should probably just make a site 'clarifying' it page by page because it's chock full of misinformation and certainly a contender for the single worst pop-sci book published in modern times. It's the analog of people thinking the Moon landing was a hoax because they read some misleading article about the Van Allen Belts, all of which tend to like suggesting you'd need a radiation shield which would probably have gotten the astronauts killed due to bremsstrahlung, but I digress.